BOOK REVIEW ON ‘INSIDE PAKISTAN ARMY’ BY CAREY SCHOFIELD

BackgroundResearch by Carey Schofield

1. Carey Schofield is a author and journalist and the writer of the best-selling Inside the Soviet Army and The Russian Elite: Inside the Airborne Forces. She is a sing chap at Oxford University.

2. The writer, a British author spent seven old ages ( 2004-2011 ) composing the book and was closely associated with Gen Pervez Musharraf & A ; Gen Pervez kayani, the heads of Army staff. She interacted with a big No of officers at all degrees and soldiers carry oning interviews and sing distant boundary line outstations to acquire a first-hand history of the state of affairs, a privilege ne’er given earlier on such a consistent footing to Pakistani or foreign journalists.

3. She visited Pakistan ‘s military academy at Abbottabad, and writes glowingly of how the establishment “spares nil in its pursuit for excellence. She was profoundly influenced by Maj Gen Faisal Alavi, former GOC of the SSG in her positions on conditions & A ; issues in the Pak ground forces and its actions during its run against terrorists in the tribal countries along the Durrand Line.

4. The writer was assisted by Inter- Services Public Relations Directorate under Maj Gen Shaukat Sultan And Maj Gen Athar Abbas. Outside the ground forces, she was assisted by Afzal Khan and his girl. A direct entree to higher echelons of the ground forces ensured a uninterrupted flow of information for her to get at an history of what existed in the ground forces, how it evolved and how it went about helping United States of America in its Global war on panic.

2

Chapter Wise Summary

5. Chapter 1: The Question of the Pak Army.The book starts with oppugning the competency of Pakistan ground forces and of Gen Kayani in peculiar in the wake of the riddance of Osama bin laden by United States. It delves into how the incident led to plumping of army’s popularity to its lowest wane since 1971 war with India and how the Pak ground forces is overstretched in its dply on its western and eastern boundary lines.

6. Chapter 2: The Topographic point of the Army in Pakistan. It gives a gen background of Pakistan with regard to its states, human ecology, faith and the assorted wars it has fought with India since Independence. It gives a brief history on the prevailing corruptness in Pakistan society and the bench in peculiar. It summarises how professional and good organised is Pakistan ground forces and how Islam has shaped its spiritual mentality, besides the external menaces Pakistan is confronting chiefly from India.

7. Chapter 3: How the Pak Army Got to Be Where It is Today. It covers the history of Pakistan from 632 AD, after the decease of prophesier Mohammad till its independency and how Islam forms the footing of the country’s individuality and its civilization. It throws visible radiation on how Gilgit-Baltistan became a portion of Pakistan in 1947, its assorted wars with India and the merger of the deluxe provinces of Dir, Chitral and most imp Swat in 1969. It besides covers the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, the proxy war in Afghanistan and the outgrowth of Taliban.

8. Chapter 4: Fauji life. It covers the behavior of classs, continuance of trg, the life of Gentleman Cadets & A ; Personality devp activities at Pakistan Military Academy at Abbotabad. It delves into the type of people fall ining the ground forces soon as compared to antecedently from flush households and public schools. Its dramatic similarity to trg at IMA, Dehradun is notable. The life of soldiers in units and public assistance activities are besides highlighted.

3

Analysis Of Allotted Part

9. The chapter on the creative activity of Pakistan conveys the invasion of Sindh by Muhammad Bin Qasim in 711 AD as the critical founding measure for the ulterior creative activity of Pakistan. Embracing the historical, ideological paradigm about Pakistan ‘s beginnings, the writer goes on to depict the Pakistan Army ‘s “ narrative ” as “ a powerful reading of the yesteryear, perchance more of import than the province itself is confounding.

10. While diging on Pak’s dealingss with its neighbors, The writer agrees with the position that Pakistan “ is beset by enemies ” and is “ engaged in an experiential battle ” with India, but do non offer any grounds to confirm her averments except the fact that she was told so by her Pakistan Army hosts. As an illustration of India ‘s sick purpose towards Pakistan, writer provinces that the Indian national anthem “ refers possessively to Sindh ” mentioning to the 2nd line of the anthem where Sindh is mentioned along with other parts like Punjab, Gujarat and Maratha. She was clearly non state, or failed to research, the beginnings of the Indian national anthem, which was originally a verse form written in 1911. A verse form written about four decennaries before Pakistan ‘s Independence in 1947 doesn’t service as grounds of India ‘s purposes towards Pakistan

11. The merger of the deluxe provinces of Dir, Chitral and Swat in 1969 merely reflects on how loose was the clasp of the federal govt in Pakistan since 1947. The tribal parts have since witnessed agitation and have challenged the legitimacy of the government at Islamabad.

12. The ground for Army’s laterality appears to be within Pakistan, is non because the Army has taken over civilian infinite through repeated military intercessions but because the Army was and remains the “ lone thing that works in the state. The author’s glory of PMA, Abbotabad is besides non justified as the same modus operandi is followed in any professional ground forces.

4

Overall Analysis Of Inside The Pakistan Army

13. A more disposed description of the rubric of the book would be “the universe harmonizing to Pakistan’s military officers.” — subjects that would specify it as a book about the establishment — the book covers all these topics in a individual chapter and devotes full chapters to a treatment of the creative activity of Pakistan, the function of the ground forces, its political orientation and its topographic point in Pakistan. There are besides separate chapters on Pakistan’s intelligence services, on former Chief of Army General Pervez Musharraf and on the current war in the Pashtun tribal countries surrounding Afghanistan.

14. The full chapter on the Pakistani intelligence services ( ISI ) is based about wholly on an interview with one former caput of the bureau. The chapter is focused on portraying the “correct” image of the ISI, countering unfavorable judgment both within and outside Pakistan, every bit good as to happen out the “motives” of those who are assailing the bureau. While we are provided with a basic thought of the ISI’s internal organisational construction, the purpose is to portray the ISI as an bureau wrongly blamed by others. No non-ISI ground forces officers or civilians are interviewed for their positions and there is no attempt to compare the claims of the author’s interviewees with other beginnings.

15. In the chapters on the on-going battle with the activists, the writer unquestioningly accepts the Pakistan ground forces narration on the Afghan war. Like the Pakistan ground forces, she repeatedly states that the Pakistan ground forces does non miss purposes, merely capablenesss, in contending the activists. There is no effort to turn to U.S. concerns about Pakistan’s links with the Taliban and the Haqqani web.

16. It is obvious from the entree of the writer to the Army, all her interviews had been arranged as portion of a public dealingss exercising by the Pakistan Army and comes across more as propaganda than a existent narrative.

5

Position

17.Author’s Perspective. Carey Schofield’s entree to high ranking military officers and visits to remote boundary line outstation, as besides interviews with soldiers helped her in organizing positions on Pak ground forces and its primacy in Pak maintaining in head the socio – economic conditions in the state. Her positions on creative activity of Pakistan and external menaces are clearly influenced and devoid of facts. Her friendly relationship with Maj Gen Faizal Alavi seems to hold caused an emotional turbulence in her and made her write against the really military that helped her in composing the book.

18.Current Position. Pakistan’s function in the American war on panic in Afghanistan has come under intense examination in recent times because of its support to the Haqqani web, which is runing in Afghanistan and is viewed by Pak as necessary in its pursuit for achieving strategic deepness in Afghanistan against India. Pak is accused of go throughing critical int to Taliban wrt ISAF ops thereby haltering its Opss. Pak has besides actively protested against the deathly drone attks that have been successful in extinguishing the leading of Al- Qaida and Taliban. The ISAF is slated to go forth Afghanistan in late 2014.

19.Future Position. After the backdown of ISAF in 2014, the state of affairs in Afghanistan is improbable to travel back to 1989, after the Soviet backdown, as the ISAF Opss have ensured heavy reverses to the Taliban, besides there is now a trained Afghan standing army supported by American drone attks to maintain the local reserves at bay. There is likely to be a sit wherein the security forces will be challenged by Taliban & A ; other militia’s that may take control over certain parts of the state but decidedly non like the 1996 coup d’etat of Afghanistan by Taliban.