Orson Welles wrote: “ Were born entirely, we live entirely, we die entirely. Merely through our love and friendly relationship can we make the semblance for the minute that were non entirely. ” In The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, and The Old Man and The Sea, written by Ernest Hemingway, both characters deal with their solitariness by different methods and terminal in different ways.
The first of import point to notice is what are Jay Gatsby and Santiago ‘s jobs and the manner they cope with it. Indeed, in The Great Gatsby, the chief character, Jay Gatsby, is a affluent, cryptic adult male life in a immense abode in West Egg. Every dark, his house is the theatre of his legendary parties, celebrations and intoxicant. It ‘s so said, in page 40 five that “ At least one time a two weeks a corps of caterers came down with several hundred pess of canvas and plenty colored visible radiations to do a Christmas tree of Gatsby ‘s tremendous garden ” . Furthermore, he lives entirely with the staff in charge of the good looking of his house, like said: “ [ aˆ¦ ] eight retainers, including an excess nurseryman, toiled all twenty-four hours with swabs and scrubbing-brushes and cocks and garden-shears, mending the depredations of the dark before. ” The self-contradictory thing in The Great Gatsby is that, although his life seems astonishing and ever full of amusement with his house full of invitees, most of them he does non cognize: “ In his bluish garden work forces and misss came and went [ aˆ¦ ] ” , in existent facts this facade is merely the manner he could happen to avoid his shocking solitariness. Because in world, Jay Gatsby has merely one dream: to see once more his young person love, Daisy Buchanan. But the miss of his dream is already married to an chesty millionaire who lives in East Egg, Tom. Everything seems to divide them, except possibly, the lone adult male who does non bask Gatsby immense parties, the storyteller of the narrative, Nick Carraway, a immature salesman, following door neighbour of Gatsby, who happens to be Daisy ‘s cousin. During the narrative, Jay Gatsby admits that the lone ground he came here in West Egg was to be closer from Daisy because he knew she was populating nigh. Actually, in order to give himself a opportunity to happen back his old love, he inflicts himself a alone life.
In The Old Man and The Sea, Santiago suffers the same solitariness than Jay Gatsby. Fisherman with a bad repute and hapless, the old adult male lives entirely since his lone friend, his immature learner Manolin had been forbidden to sail with Santiago because destiny did non gave him a fish about eight four yearss. In the 4th page of the book, we learn that destiny seems to be cabaling against Santiago because we can read that it was non the first long period without fish: “ Remember how you went 87 yearss without fish and so caught large 1s every twenty-four hours for three hebdomads. ” That is why the parents of Manolin decided to set him on another boat that the old adult male considers as a “ lucky boat ” , even if the immature learner continues to take attention of Santiago and attempts to convert him to travel fishing with him. But the old fisherman wants to turn out himself that he is non excessively old to catch a large fish and is non “ decidedly salao ” , the Cuban word for an luckless individual. This is how Santiago boards for a barbarous conflict against himself and against a fish which will do him a batch of strivings. Indeed, the old adult male will hold to confront the fish for three yearss and three darks, during which 1 he will be profoundly on his ain with his solitariness. Actually he will even speak with a portion of himself, as his manus with in the 40 6th page: “ Come on manus. Please come on ” , as it was an independent portion of him. He will besides happen a friendly relationship with the fish like he says in the 50 6th page: “ The fish is my friend excessively ” . Even if in the terminal, his end is to kill him, he besides finds out that because of the fish ‘s great self-respect, no 1 will be dignified of eating the marlin.
So we can state that in both The Great Gatsby and The Old Man and The Sea, the of import secret plan is how the chief characters deal with their solitariness. Actually, this solitariness as the linking yarn of the narratives will non take to the same sort of terminal. We could about state that Santiago ‘s terminal is better than Jay Gatsby ‘s one, by many ways.
Indeed, in The Great Gatsby, Jay ‘s happy stoping will non be the one he was trusting for. Actually, Daisy, the miss of his dreams, will non desire to talk to him once more after a tragic accident where Gatsby could be accused of the slaying of a adult female who happens to be Tom ‘s kept woman. At the terminal of the narrative, Gatsby dies, killed by the murdered adult female ‘s hubby, before he committed suicide. Later, Nick Carraway will happen out that it was Daisy who killed the adult female, but she will non be present to Gatsby ‘s funeral. When Nick tries to garner together people who could hold known Jay, merely three individuals will demo up: Jay ‘s male parent and the “ owl-eyed ” adult male Nick met at one of Gatsby ‘s parties in the library and Nick, seeing himself as Gatsby ‘s best friend. This shows clearly how Gatsby ‘s entertaining life was bogus. He, who was looking for love, concealing behind a wall of daftness and parties eventually got the opposite number to decease entirely, without the 1 he loved who wholly ignored him.
In The Old Man and The Sea, after the long and seeking battle, Santiago eventually acquire the upper manus of the large fish. Santiago comes back saddened by the loss of his beloved fish. Indeed, what was the cogent evidence he was still able to catch fish, was devoured by sharks on Santiago ‘s manner back to the shore and merely allow a skeleton. The weak old adult male, back from his heroic poem arouse all the same the esteem of the fishermen and Manolin who was impatiently waiting for him, so happy to see him alive that when “ he saw the old adult male was take a breathing ” and when “ he saw the old adult male ‘s custodies [ aˆ¦ ] he started to shout. “ , written at the 90 5th page. But for Santiago, the point is that everything is to make once more, he is back at his point of going with no fish to sell on the market, the one about he had thought “ How many people will he feed? ” is now merely a memory. But unlike Jay Gatsby in The great Gatsby, Santiago will non stop entirely because he will be sustained by Manolin who did non stand to wait that long to cognize if the old adult male was alive or non and who felt guilty to hold allow him travel off entirely. For Santiago, this battle and this isolation have brought back his learner and possibly have permitted to demo other fishermen his value allowing behind his old repute to be a good-for-naught because of his old age.
In The Old Man and The Sea, written by Ernest Hemingway and The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, the chief characters have to get by with their solitariness. Even if their solitariness has taken different visual aspects: amusement, parties, celebrity and wealth for Jay Gatsby, and modus operandi, destiny and poorness for Santiago. The fact is that really, the 1 who seemed to hold everything to be happy does non hold a better terminal that the 1 that everything led to sadness.
About his book, Hemingway wrote that: “ No good book has of all time been written that has in it symbols arrived at beforehand and stuck in. … I tried to do a existent old adult male, a existent male child, a existent sea and a existent fish and existent sharks. But if I made them good and true plenty they would intend many things ” as F. Scott Fitzgerald mentioned Gatsby as “ person who had great possible that he ne’er reached ” . In these two books, solitariness could be seen more as an interior battle, as the conflict to hold the bravery to confront the elements, that one clasp all the winning cards or non.
Marine Bourdet
L1 CLE
[ 6120 caracteres ]