Contrasting Nature Of The Siblings In Antigone English Literature Essay

The diverseness of human nature and the differences in the political orientation have ever been a portion of our society, irrespective of the civilization or nationality. This is apparent in the two plants explored in this essay. In the Grecian play Antigone by Sophocles, Antigone and Ismene the two sisters appear to hold a blunt contrast between them. Similarly in The House Of The Spirits the two Trueba brothers Nicholas and Jamie despite their blood connexions have antithetical personalities. This essay aims to uncover the difference between the characters and look into the intent and cause of this contrast.

Antigone ‘s character in the drama Antigone is similar to the significance of her name “ inflexible ”[ 1 ]. The struggle in the play is sing the entombment of Polyneices the brother of Antigone and Ismene. Creon the male monarch passed a announcement to the citizens that “ the organic structure of Polyneices must non be buried nor mourned ”[ 2 ]as he is considered a treasonist. In the prologue of the drama Antigone questioned Ismene about the announcement “ what is this proclamationaˆ¦.whole metropolis? Do you understand it? Have you heard it? Or do n’t you know that penalty tantrum for enemies is coming to those we love? ”[ 3 ]The inquiries posed by Antigone are really rhetoric, which suggests her rebellious nature and brings out her strong dissension with the announcement. Her audacious act of acquiring Ismene out of the castle Gatess, considered unconventional for Greek adult female, shows Antigone ‘s extremist nature and lays the foundation for her hereafter brave actions. In contrast to the independent character of Antigone, Ismene is portrayed as a really apathetic and submissive character when she answers Antigone stating that “ non a word has come to me, sweet or painful ”[ 4 ].

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The chief difference between the two sisters ‘ political orientation is that Ismene perceives state of affairss rationally and argues that ‘might is right ‘[ 5 ]. She emphasizes this point by adding that adult females are born non to contend against work forces, and that “ it is mindless to transgress our bounds ”[ 6 ]. While/on the other manus Antigone is of the sentiment that it is the Godhead Torahs that affair and non the superficial human Torahs meant to provide to their egoistic nature. For her it is the self-respect and award of her household which comes foremost, no affair what the effect possibly, even decease.

Equally much as black accentuates white, the contrasting character of Ismene Acts of the Apostless as a foil to anneal Antigone ‘s extremist actions to a more acceptable visible radiation. This contrast besides helps us to separate Antigone from the conventional Greek adult female of that epoch and to appreciate her audaciousness. The significance of this contrast can be attributed to the fact that what Antigone was trying to make was really far-fetched and harmonizing to some Greeks it might be disloyal as good. Therefore by facing the over rebellious and righteous Antigone against a cowed and submissive Ismene, the author forces the audience to accept Antigone as a supporter and O.K. her class of action. It besides develops understanding and support towards Antigone

The House of The Spirits portrays similar characters in Jaime and Nicholas. Though both of them are twins, their drastically different visual aspects could bode their oil and H2O similar personalities as we see subsequently in the text. “ prophesying free love, citing Freud, imbibing Pernod and dancing flamenco ”[ 7 ], Nicholas was more concerned about his societal image than the virtue in his actions. With “ A naming for both forfeit and asceticism ”[ 8 ], Jamie had a really reserved yet benevolent personality. His dedication to the survey of medical specialty made him give up all his secular ties and pleasances. All his apparels and money used to stop up with the hapless. He used his house more as a societal refuge for people in demand. While Jamie is one of those perfect theoretical accounts who believed in societal public assistance, Nicholas was interested in scoring the adult females through gallant Acts of the Apostless. After Nicholas ‘s initial chase of celebrity, he so becomes obsessed with following the religious way. Jamie could ne’er tie in himself with things that bore no societal utility, whereas Nicholas ne’er had these unworldly virtuousnesss that would do him interested in any societal work.

The difference between the two brothers was non merely restricted to their nature and actions but even their attack to people whom they cared for – like Amanda and Alba. As her fellow Nicholas liked Amanda merely because she ne’er expected anything in return for her love. In contrast Jamie loved and stood by her because of her “ free, fond and adventuresome personality ”[ 9 ]. Both Nicholas and Jamie fostered the development of Alba in distinguishable ways. Nicholas with his spiritualistic involvements taught her to defy hurting and heartache, develop endurance and his macabre “ fakeer ‘s fast ones ”[ 10 ], while Jamie gave her a more rational exposure. Along with playing imaginative games, Jamie discussed subjects like “ the advantages and disadvantages of life in the jungle ”[ 11 ], provided her with medical books and argued approximately political political orientations.

We notice that although both the brothers are shown to hold bizarre ideas and actions, Jamie has been shown in a positive visible radiation throughout the novel. Isabel achieves this by comparing the bizarre yet baronial actions of Jamie with Nicholas ‘s. Besides by contrasting Jamie ‘s fondness with that of Nicholas ‘s lust towards Amanda, the writer succeeds in making understanding and support for Jamie.

The writers of both the plants use the contrasting character to reflect two different political orientations to the reader. In the play Antigone, Sophocles through the statements of Antigone and Ismene makes the reader aware of the features of two conflicting political thoughts i.e. democracy and absolutism. Antigone embodies a democratic citizen contending for the rights of herself and her brother, whereas Ismene ‘s character is a victim of absolutism, whose ideas and actions have been bound by the bossy King Creon. Similar form is besides observed in the novel The House Of The Spirits, wherein Isabel uses the contrast of the siblings to suggest to the readers about the effects of two political systems. Here, Jamie ‘s selfless actions and his severe life exhibit an unpretentious society based on equality under a socialist regulation. And Nicholas ‘s pretentious life style and his apathy towards enduring demonstrate the capitalist policy prefering the privileged.

I personally feel in The House Of The Spirits, the contrast between the twin brothers is unconditioned and bit by bit becomes sharper as they pursue their diametral waies. Their different personalities might hold stemmed due to the assorted mentality of society during that period, when socialism and capitalist economy were at par with each other. This inconclusiveness is witnessed towards the terminal of the novel where the writer describes everything in sunglassess of Grey. While praising the free market for refilling stocks, she at the same time condemns the policy for doing life unaffordable. Perversely, the contrast in Antigone between the sisters is forced due to external force per unit area i.e. from the society. Here, Ismene, epitomizing the conventional Greek adult female, unwillingly resignations to the King ‘s judgement. Following the conventional norm of fifth century BC Greek civilization, but discreetly sharing sentiment with Antigone, she chose non to arise.

We can impute the struggle of the political political orientations in both the books to the political state of affairss of the several civilizations. In the fifth century B.C. although Greece had democratic elements in administration but it still was nothingness of freedom for the adult females. Thus Antigone might be Sophocles ‘ effort to do the position of adult females more outstanding in the society. The House Of The Spirits was set in Chile. This state, during the 70s, was under military regulation during which a free market economic system was forced. This worsened the economic jobs and curbed the civil autonomies of the state. Thus through the conflicting political orientations represented by the siblings, the novel might be Isabel ‘s effort to show her position towards the political state of affairs in support of socialism. As Allende ‘s uncle was a outstanding communist leader, the fact that Isabel favored communism and disapproved of capitalist economy seems no surprise to me.

Although contrasting natures is non really important to plot patterned advance, it adds a new dimension in the word picture of the siblings in both the plants. It appears that the contrast amongst the characters in both the novels is used as a tool to pull the readers ‘ attending to an inexplicit yet important subject of ideological struggles prevalent in society. It compels the readers to take a stance on an issue and stimulate emotions towards the character. This induced support for the character bit by bit translates into support for its political orientation, thereby alining the reader ‘s sentiment with the writer ‘s intent in both the plants. We notice that even people with blood ties have different thought procedures and this feature will ne’er discontinue to be a portion of world, irrespective of the cultural development.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *